By Attorney Patrick M. Winn
If the Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board (SORB) sends you a proposed classification, check the deadline on the letter and speak with a lawyer before you give the Board your account. You can represent yourself, and if you qualify financially, you can ask for appointed counsel. My advice is to have a lawyer at your hearing. One of the most important decisions you’ll make is whether to testify at all.
Yes. Even if you appear by video, you testify under oath if you take the stand. The Board’s attorney can cross-examine you, and the hearing examiner can use your answers in deciding your classification. If you have a pending criminal case involving the same facts, talk to your lawyer before answering questions about it. An admission you make here can put your defense at risk.
If you pleaded guilty or a jury found you guilty, SORB treats that finding as final. Denying the offense of conviction can cost you credit for treatment. In my experience, disputing an allegation that was never charged, was dismissed, or ended in an acquittal does not ordinarily count against you as denial.
SORB files often contain poorly supported allegations about uncharged conduct, drawn from DCF reports, police reports, and other sources. My job is to show the examiner exactly where the evidence falls short and argue forcefully that unreliable allegations cannot be held against you. I can make that argument without putting you on the stand.
The risk factors in 803 CMR 1.33 are qualitative. The examiner has to weigh them reasonably in light of your circumstances. Counting the factors on each side tells you very little. Experience with SORB hearings helps me decide which evidence deserves the examiner’s attention and how to get it into the record.
Take Factor 31, physical condition. I represented a client who was confined to a hospital bed. His health was one factor, but it went to the heart of the case. What danger did he actually pose? The evidence showed no cognizable risk of reoffense or danger to the public. Keeping him on the registry on that record would have violated his right to due process.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court explained why in Doe No. 76819 v. Sex Offender Registry Board, 480 Mass. 212, 219–220 (2018). When you seek to end registration, you must first offer credible evidence that your circumstances have changed and you no longer pose a risk to public safety. The Board then has to prove by clear and convincing evidence that continued registration is justified.
In one of my SORB cases, my client had been classified at Level 2 for more than two decades. The Board recommended lowering him to Level 1, which still would have required him to register. We asked for complete relief. I presented evidence of more than 22 years without a new offense in the community, his age, his medical conditions, and his stable home. The hearing examiner ended his obligation to register.
I represent clients before SORB throughout Massachusetts, including Boston and MetroWest. My office is in Woburn, and we can review your notice and prepare for a remote hearing wherever you live. Call me at (857) 415-2415 or send me a message. Have the Board’s letter handy so we can start with what it recommends and when you need to respond.
Over 50 five-star reviews on Avvo. For a free, confidential case assessment, tell us briefly what happened and how to reach you using the form below, or call (857) 415-2415