By Attorney Patrick M. Winn
If the Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board (SORB) issues a final Level 2 or Level 3 classification, you generally have 30 calendar days from receipt of the decision to file a complaint for judicial review in Superior Court. That’s a Chapter 30A appeal. Filing the complaint does not automatically stop SORB from publishing your information online. If publication is imminent, you can ask the court for a stay. G.L. c. 6, § 178M and 803 CMR 1.24.
File a paper complaint with the Superior Court clerk. You can file in the county where you live or in Suffolk County. Name the Sex Offender Registry Board as defendant. Identify the final decision, when you received it, what the examiner got wrong, and the relief you want. Attach the decision if available. Include a signed civil action cover sheet and the filing fee. The court excludes sex offender classification reviews from e-filing. Superior Court filing guide · E-filing exclusions.
Once the clerk issues the summons, serve it and the complaint on SORB and the Attorney General’s Boston office. Certified or registered mail is an option. Serve any other party to the agency proceeding and file proof of service. Mass. R. Civ. P. 4(d)(3) · G.L. c. 30A, § 14(1)–(2).
Download the court’s complete blank Chapter 30A complaint (PDF). Compare it with the anonymized first page of our SORB complaint (PDF).
Protecting your identity. Section 178M requires the court to keep the proceedings and records confidential. In this case, I also asked to use a pseudonym and separately asked for a preliminary injunction to stop SORB from publishing the classification while the appeal was pending. See the original first pages of our motion to proceed under a pseudonym, motion to impound, and preliminary injunction application and supporting papers (PDFs).
Once SORB serves the hearing record, you generally have 30 days to serve SORB with your Rule 12(c) motion for judgment on the pleadings and a brief citing specific record pages. If the judge rules later on a preliminary motion covered by Standing Order 1-96, paragraph 3, the 30 days run from that ruling. SORB then has 30 days from service to respond. Its response counts as a cross-motion.
You then promptly file one Rule 9A package with the clerk. It includes your motion and brief, SORB’s response, and any reply. Send the other parties a notice listing what you filed and include the notice in the package. The clerk schedules a hearing. The judge generally decides the appeal on the record made at your SORB classification hearing. Standing Order 1-96, ¶¶ 3–5 · Superior Court Rule 9A.
View the anonymized Rule 9A examples (PDF). The three pages show the merits motion, the list of papers, and the notice of filing.
SORB recommended Level 3 for a client whose federal convictions involved producing and possessing sexual images of minors. Neither offense involved physical contact with a victim. At the hearing, I emphasized the suffocating terms of his lifetime federal supervised release. He needed his probation officer’s approval to go online. His computers were monitored and subject to unannounced inspection. He was barred from contact with minors. Those restrictions directly addressed how his prior offenses occurred. We also documented two completed treatment programs, stable housing and employment, and family support. The hearing examiner classified him at Level 2.
We appealed. Level 2 requires clear and convincing evidence of a moderate risk of reoffense, a moderate degree of dangerousness, and a public safety interest served by internet publication. The examiner identified whom my client might target. She never found that a future offense would likely involve sexual contact or put someone in reasonable fear of it. Given his non-contact history, the judge ruled that the record did not support the finding of moderate dangerousness. Doe No. 496501 v. Sex Offender Registry Board, 482 Mass. 643, 656–660 (2019).
The judge vacated the Level 2 classification and sent the case back to SORB for the missing findings. The examiner had already given full credit for supervision. The judge encouraged her to explain how those restrictions affected this client’s risk. The court left the ultimate classification open, including whether Level 1 was warranted.
If you’ve received a final SORB decision, contact me about a Massachusetts SORB appeal. Have the decision and the date you received it handy.
Over 50 five-star reviews on Avvo. For a free, confidential case assessment, tell us briefly what happened and how to reach you using the form below, or call (857) 415-2415